Doughty Street Chambers Geoffrey Robertson QC Serious Organised Crime Bank Fraud Bribery “Forensics Files” – DOUGHTY STREET CHAMBERS AMAL CLOONEY – AXIS – DOUGHTY STREET CHAMBERS PATRICK O’CONNOR QC – “THE DOUGHTY STREET CHAMBERS PATRICK O’CONNOR QC CRIME SYNDICATE BANK FRAUD BRIBERY CASE STORY” – THE BAR STANDARDS BOARD CHAIR DAME TESSA BLACKSTONE – “THE CHURCH COMMISSIONERS TOP TRUSTEE HSBC BANK GROUP CRIME SYNDICATE CASE STORY” – EUROPOL DIRECTOR CATHERINE DE BOLLE – AXIS – SPANISH NATIONAL POLICE CORPS DIRECTOR GENERAL FRANCISCO PARDO PIQUERAS – AXIS – INTERPOL DIRECTOR GENERAL JURGEN STOCK – CPS Criminal “Standard of Proof” Prosecution Files – GIBRALTAR FINANCIAL SERVICES COMMISSION – ROYAL GIBRALTAR POLICE COMMISSIONER RICHARD ULLGER QPM – SECRETARY OF STATE FOR JUSTICE RT HON ROBERT BUCKLAND QC MP – HM ATTORNEY GENERAL RT HON MICHAEL ELLIS QC MP – CARROLL FOUNDATION TRUST = NAME-SWITCH = GERALD 6TH DUKE OF SUTHERLAND TRUST – PRIME MINISTER RT HON BORIS JOHNSON MP – 10 DOWNING STREET CABINET SECRETARY SIMON CASE – CHANCELLOR OF THE EXCHEQUER RT HON RISHI SUNAK MP – UK NATIONAL SECURITY ADVISER SIR STEPHEN LOVEGROVE – HOME SECRETARY RT HON PRITI PATEL MP – CABINET OFFICE PERMANENT SECRETARY ALEX CHISHOLM – UK CIVIL SERVICE CEO ALEX CHISHOLM – MI5 SECURITY SERVICE DIRECTOR GENERAL KENNETH MCCALLUM – SIS SECRET INTELLIGENCE SERVICE MI6 DIRECTOR GENERAL RICHARD MOORE – The Royal Courts of Justice Biggest Transnational Crime Syndicate Case in the World ...
BBC Two – Newsnight News Media Blackout Case – “The Royal Family Identity Story” – SCOTLAND FIRST MINISTER NICOLA STURGEON – AXIS – SCOTLAND JUSTICE SECRETARY KEITH BROWN – AXIS – SCOTLAND POLICE AUTHORITY CHAIR MARTYN EVANS – AXIS – SCOTLAND POLICE CHIEF CONSTABLE IAIN LIVINGSTONE QPM – “THE COLIN SUTHERLAND QC IDENTITY THEFT BANK FRAUD BRIBERY STORY” – LORD JUSTICE GENERAL RT HON LORD COLIN CARLOWAY QC – AXIS – THE QUEEN’S SOLICITORS FARRER & CO – THE CLAN SUTHERLAND – “THE ROYAL WARRANT IDENTITY STORY” – THE MASTER OF SUTHERLAND – THE EARL OF SUTHERLAND – THE DUKE OF SUTHERLAND – THE ROYAL REGIMENT OF SCOTLAND – THE ARGYLL AND SUTHERLAND HIGHLANDERS MUSEUM – HM Queen Elizabeth II Head of State “Sovereign Powers” Gerald 6th Duke of Sutherland Marquess of Stafford Earl Gower – Gerald J. H. Carroll Forged Birth Certificate “Sealed Records” – THE COURT OF THE LORD LYON EDINBURGH SCOTLAND – LORD LYON KING OF ARMS DR JOSEPH MORROW QC – ALEXANDER DOUGLAS HAMILTON 16TH DUKE OF HAMILTON AND 13TH DUKE OF BRANDON – “THE KEEPER OF THE PALACE OF HOLYROODHOUSE IDENTITY STORY” – LORD HIGH CONSTABLE OF SCOTLAND MERLIN HAY 24TH EARL OF ERROLL – HRH THE PRINCESS MARINA DUCHESS OF KENT AND GEORGE 5TH DUKE OF SUTHERLAND – GERALD 6TH DUKE OF SUTHERLAND TRUST = NAME-SWITCH = CARROLL FOUNDATION TRUST – HM KING EDWARD VIII – HRH THE PRINCE EDWARD DUKE OF WINDSOR “THE GODFATHER” – SIR WINSTON S. CHURCHILL “THE GODFATHER” – HRH THE PRINCE OF WALES DUKE OF ROTHESAY – THE LORD HIGH COMMISSIONER TO THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF THE CHURCH OF SCOTLAND HRH PRINCE WILLIAM EARL OF STRATHEARN – THE ROYAL ARCHIVES THE ROUND TOWER WINDSOR CASTLE – DORNOCH CATHEDRAL DORNOCH HIGHLANDS SCOTLAND – THE HOUSE OF TONGUE HIGHLANDS SCOTLAND – DUNROBIN CASTLE GOLSPIE HIGHLANDS SCOTLAND – HM LORD LIEUTENANT OF SUTHERLAND DR MONICA MAIN – The Royal Courts of Justice Most Famous Identity Theft Liquidation Bank Case in the World
First Minister of Scotland Nicola Sturgeon – “The Royal Family Identity Story” – CABINET SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE SCOTLAND KEITH BROWN – AXIS – SCOTLAND POLICE AUTHORITY CHAIR MARTYN EVANS – AXIS – SCOTLAND POLICE CHIEF CONSTABLE IAIN LIVINGSTONE QPM – “THE COLIN SUTHERLAND QC IDENTITY THEFT BANK FRAUD BRIBERY STORY” – LORD JUSTICE GENERAL RT HON LORD COLIN CARLOWAY QC – AXIS – THE QUEEN’S SOLICITORS FARRER & CO – THE CLAN SUTHERLAND – “THE ROYAL WARRANT IDENTITY STORY” – THE MASTER OF SUTHERLAND – THE EARL OF SUTHERLAND – THE DUKE OF SUTHERLAND – THE ROYAL REGIMENT OF SCOTLAND – THE ARGYLL AND SUTHERLAND HIGHLANDERS MUSEUM – HM Queen Elizabeth II Head of State “Sovereign Powers” Gerald 6th Duke of Sutherland Marquess of Stafford Earl Gower – Gerald J. H. Carroll Forged Birth Certificate “Sealed Records” – THE COURT OF THE LORD LYON EDINBURGH SCOTLAND – LORD LYON KING OF ARMS DR JOSEPH MORROW QC – ALEXANDER DOUGLAS HAMILTON 16TH DUKE OF HAMILTON AND 13TH DUKE OF BRANDON – “THE KEEPER OF THE PALACE OF HOLYROODHOUSE IDENTITY STORY” – LORD HIGH CONSTABLE OF SCOTLAND MERLIN HAY 24TH EARL OF ERROLL – HRH THE PRINCESS MARINA DUCHESS OF KENT AND GEORGE 5TH DUKE OF SUTHERLAND – GERALD 6TH DUKE OF SUTHERLAND TRUST = NAME-SWITCH = CARROLL FOUNDATION TRUST – HM KING EDWARD VIII – HRH THE PRINCE EDWARD DUKE OF WINDSOR “THE GODFATHER” – SIR WINSTON S. CHURCHILL “THE GODFATHER” – HRH THE PRINCE OF WALES DUKE OF ROTHESAY – THE LORD HIGH COMMISSIONER TO THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF THE CHURCH OF SCOTLAND HRH PRINCE WILLIAM EARL OF STRATHEARN – THE ROYAL ARCHIVES THE ROUND TOWER WINDSOR CASTLE – DORNOCH CATHEDRAL HIGHLANDS SCOTLAND – THE HOUSE OF TONGUE HIGHLANDS SCOTLAND – DUNROBIN CASTLE HIGHLANDS SCOTLAND – HM LORD LIEUTENANT OF SUTHERLAND DR MONICA MAIN – Royal Courts of Justice Most Famous Identity Theft Case in the World
Scotland Justice Secretary Keith Brown – “The Royal Family Identity Story” – SCOTLAND FIRST MINISTER NICOLA STURGEON – AXIS – SCOTLAND POLICE AUTHORITY CHAIR MARTYN EVANS – AXIS – SCOTLAND POLICE CHIEF CONSTABLE IAIN LIVINGSTONE QPM – “THE COLIN SUTHERLAND QC IDENTITY THEFT BANK FRAUD BRIBERY STORY” – LORD JUSTICE GENERAL RT HON LORD COLIN CARLOWAY QC – AXIS – THE QUEEN’S SOLICITORS FARRER & CO – THE CLAN SUTHERLAND – “THE ROYAL WARRANT IDENTITY STORY” – THE MASTER OF SUTHERLAND – THE EARL OF SUTHERLAND – THE DUKE OF SUTHERLAND – THE ROYAL REGIMENT OF SCOTLAND – THE ARGYLL AND SUTHERLAND HIGHLANDERS MUSEUM – HM Queen Elizabeth II Head of State “Sovereign Powers” Gerald 6th Duke of Sutherland Marquess of Stafford Earl Gower – Gerald J. H. Carroll Forged Birth Certificate “Sealed Records” – THE COURT OF THE LORD LYON EDINBURGH SCOTLAND – LORD LYON KING OF ARMS DR JOSEPH MORROW QC – ALEXANDER DOUGLAS HAMILTON 16TH DUKE OF HAMILTON AND 13TH DUKE OF BRANDON – “THE KEEPER OF THE PALACE OF HOLYROODHOUSE IDENTITY STORY” – LORD HIGH CONSTABLE OF SCOTLAND MERLIN HAY 24TH EARL OF ERROLL – HRH THE PRINCESS MARINA DUCHESS OF KENT AND GEORGE 5TH DUKE OF SUTHERLAND – GERALD 6TH DUKE OF SUTHERLAND TRUST = NAME-SWITCH = CARROLL FOUNDATION TRUST – HM KING EDWARD VIII – HRH THE PRINCE EDWARD DUKE OF WINDSOR “THE GODFATHER” – SIR WINSTON S. CHURCHILL “THE GODFATHER” – HRH THE PRINCE OF WALES DUKE OF ROTHESAY – THE LORD HIGH COMMISSIONER TO THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF THE CHURCH OF SCOTLAND HRH PRINCE WILLIAM EARL OF STRATHEARN – THE ROYAL ARCHIVES THE ROUND TOWER WINDSOR CASTLE – DORNOCH CATHEDRAL DORNOCH HIGHLANDS SCOTLAND – THE HOUSE OF TONGUE HIGHLANDS SCOTLAND – DUNROBIN CASTLE GOLSPIE HIGHLANDS SCOTLAND – HM LORD LIEUTENANT OF SUTHERLAND DR MONICA MAIN – The Royal Courts of Justice Most Famous Identity Theft Case in the World
Scotland Police Authority Chair Martyn Evans – “The Royal Family Identity Story” – SCOTLAND FIRST MINISTER NICOLA STURGEON – AXIS – CABINET SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE SCOTLAND KEITH BROWN – AXIS – SCOTLAND POLICE CHIEF CONSTABLE IAIN LIVINGSTONE QPM – “THE COLIN SUTHERLAND QC IDENTITY THEFT BANK FRAUD BRIBERY STORY” – LORD JUSTICE GENERAL RT HON LORD COLIN CARLOWAY QC – AXIS – THE QUEEN’S SOLICITORS FARRER & CO – THE CLAN SUTHERLAND – “THE ROYAL WARRANT IDENTITY STORY” – THE MASTER OF SUTHERLAND – THE EARL OF SUTHERLAND – THE DUKE OF SUTHERLAND – THE ROYAL REGIMENT OF SCOTLAND – THE ARGYLL AND SUTHERLAND HIGHLANDERS MUSEUM – HM Queen Elizabeth II Head of State “Sovereign Powers” Gerald 6th Duke of Sutherland Marquess of Stafford Earl Gower – Gerald J. H. Carroll Forged Birth Certificate “Sealed Records” – THE COURT OF THE LORD LYON EDINBURGH SCOTLAND – LORD LYON KING OF ARMS DR JOSEPH MORROW QC – ALEXANDER DOUGLAS HAMILTON 16TH DUKE OF HAMILTON AND 13TH DUKE OF BRANDON – “THE KEEPER OF THE PALACE OF HOLYROODHOUSE IDENTITY STORY” – LORD HIGH CONSTABLE OF SCOTLAND MERLIN HAY 24TH EARL OF ERROLL – HRH THE PRINCESS MARINA DUCHESS OF KENT AND GEORGE 5TH DUKE OF SUTHERLAND – GERALD 6TH DUKE OF SUTHERLAND TRUST = NAME-SWITCH = CARROLL FOUNDATION TRUST – HM KING EDWARD VIII – HRH THE PRINCE EDWARD DUKE OF WINDSOR “THE GODFATHER” – SIR WINSTON S. CHURCHILL “THE GODFATHER” – HRH THE PRINCE OF WALES DUKE OF ROTHESAY – THE LORD HIGH COMMISSIONER TO THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF THE CHURCH OF SCOTLAND HRH PRINCE WILLIAM EARL OF STRATHEARN – THE ROYAL ARCHIVES THE ROUND TOWER WINDSOR CASTLE – DORNOCH CATHEDRAL DORNOCH HIGHLANDS SUTHERLAND SCOTLAND – THE HOUSE OF TONGUE HIGHLANDS SCOTLAND – DUNROBIN CASTLE GOLSPIE HIGHLANDS SUTHERLAND SCOTLAND – HM LORD LIEUTENANT OF SUTHERLAND DR MONICA MAIN – THE CHURCH OF SCOTLAND – The Royal Courts of Justice Most Famous Identity Theft Bank Fraud Bribery Case in the World
HRH The Prince Philip Duke of Edinburgh – “The Uncle Philip Identity Theft Story” – HRH THE PRINCE OF WALES DUKE OF ROTHESAY CLARENCE HOUSE ST JAMES’S LONDON – “THE CROWN MOST FAMOUS IDENTITY THEFT STORY IN THE WORLD” – HRH THE PRINCESS MARINA DUCHESS OF KENT – “THE ARCHBISHOP OF CANTERBURY JUSTIN WELBY ROYAL FAMILY FORGED BIRTH CERTIFICATE IDENTITY THEFT STORY” – GEORGE 5TH DUKE OF SUTHERLAND – HM Queen Elizabeth II Head of State “Sovereign Powers” Gerald 6th Duke of Sutherland Marquess of Stafford Earl Gower “Sealed Records” – CHURCH OF ENGLAND – HRH THE PRINCE WILLIAM DUKE OF CAMBRIDGE – GERALD 6TH DUKE OF SUTHERLAND TRUST = NAME-SWITCH = CARROLL FOUNDATION TRUST – HM KING EDWARD VIII – HRH THE PRINCE EDWARD DUKE OF WINDSOR “THE GODFATHER” – SIR WINSTON S. CHURCHILL “THE GODFATHER” – HRH THE PRINCE EDWARD DUKE OF KENT – HRH PRINCE MICHAEL OF KENT – HRH PRINCESS ALEXANDRA THE HONOURABLE LADY OGILVY – THE EARL MARSHAL OF ENGLAND EDWARD FITZALAN HOWARD 18TH DUKE OF NORFOLK – THE ROYAL ARCHIVES “THE ROUND TOWER” WINDSOR CASTLE – DORNOCH CATHEDRAL DORNOCH HIGHLANDS SCOTLAND – DUNROBIN CASTLE GOLSPIE HIGHLANDS SCOTLAND – CHURCH OF SCOTLAND – Royal Courts of Justice Most Famous Identity Theft Liquidation Bank Fraud Bribery Case in the World
Elizabeth Sutherland 24th Countess of Sutherland Estate Identity Theft Fraud Bribery “Forensics Files” – ALISTAIR CHARLES ST. CLAIR JANSON – NAME-SWITCH – ALISTAIR CHARLES ST. CLAIR SUTHERLAND 25TH EARL OF SUTHERLAND – THE QUEEN’S SOLICITORS IN SCOTLAND MORTON FRASER – THE QUEEN’S SOLICITORS FARRER & CO – THE CLAN SUTHERLAND – “THE ROYAL WARRANT IDENTITY STORY” – THE MASTER OF SUTHERLAND – THE EARL OF SUTHERLAND – THE DUKE OF SUTHERLAND – THE ROYAL REGIMENT OF SCOTLAND – THE ARGYLL AND SUTHERLAND HIGHLANDERS MUSEUM – HM Queen Elizabeth II Head of State “Sovereign Powers” Gerald 6th Duke of Sutherland Marquess of Stafford Earl Gower – Gerald J. H. Carroll Forged Birth Certificate “Sealed Records” – THE COURT OF THE LORD LYON EDINBURGH SCOTLAND – LORD LYON KING OF ARMS DR JOSEPH MORROW QC – ALEXANDER DOUGLAS HAMILTON 16TH DUKE OF HAMILTON AND 13TH DUKE OF BRANDON – “THE KEEPER OF THE PALACE OF HOLYROODHOUSE IDENTITY STORY” – LORD HIGH CONSTABLE OF SCOTLAND MERLIN HAY 24TH EARL OF ERROLL – HRH THE PRINCESS MARINA DUCHESS OF KENT AND GEORGE 5TH DUKE OF SUTHERLAND – GERALD 6TH DUKE OF SUTHERLAND TRUST = NAME-SWITCH = CARROLL FOUNDATION TRUST – HM KING EDWARD VIII – HRH THE PRINCE EDWARD DUKE OF WINDSOR “THE GODFATHER” – SIR WINSTON S. CHURCHILL “THE GODFATHER” – HRH THE PRINCE OF WALES DUKE OF ROTHESAY – THE LORD HIGH COMMISSIONER TO THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF THE CHURCH OF SCOTLAND HRH PRINCE WILLIAM EARL OF STRATHEARN – DORNOCH CATHEDRAL HIGHLANDS SCOTLAND – HOUSE OF TONGUE HIGHLANDS SCOTLAND – DUNROBIN CASTLE GOLSPIE HIGHLANDS SCOTLAND – HM LORD LIEUTENANT OF SUTHERLAND DR MONICA MAIN – Royal Courts of Justice Most Famous Identity Theft Liquidation Bank Fraud Case in the World
HRH Prince Edward Duke of Kent + HRH Prince Michael of Kent + HRH Princess Alexandra The Honourable Lady Ogilvy – “The Royal Family Identity Theft Story” – SCOTLAND FIRST MINISTER NICOLA STURGEON – AXIS – CABINET SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE OF SCOTLAND KEITH BROWN – AXIS – AMPERSAND ADVOCATES EDINBURGH SCOTLAND – “THE SUPREME COURTS OF SCOTLAND IDENTITY THEFT CASE STORY” – THE PALACE OF HOLYROODHOUSE KEEPER ALEXANDER 16TH DUKE OF HAMILTON – AXIS – LORD HIGH CONSTABLE OF SCOTLAND MERLIN HAY 24TH EARL OF ERROLL – AXIS – THE COURT OF THE LORD LYON EDINBURGH SCOTLAND – HM Queen Elizabeth II Head of State Gerald 6th Duke of Sutherland “Sealed Records” – CHURCH OF ENGLAND – HRH THE PRINCE WILLIAM DUKE OF CAMBRIDGE – HRH THE PRINCE OF WALES DUKE OF ROTHESAY – HRH THE PRINCESS MARINA DUCHESS OF KENT AND GEORGE 5TH DUKE OF SUTHERLAND – GERALD 6TH DUKE OF SUTHERLAND TRUST = NAME-SWITCH = CARROLL FOUNDATION TRUST – HM KING EDWARD VIII – HRH THE PRINCE EDWARD DUKE OF WINDSOR “THE GODFATHER” – SIR WINSTON S. CHURCHILL “THE GODFATHER” – THE QUEEN’S CHAPEL OF THE SAVOY STRAND LONDON – DORNOCH CATHEDRAL DORNOCH HIGHLANDS SCOTLAND – ROYAL ARCHIVES WINDSOR CASTLE – DUNROBIN CASTLE GOLSPIE HIGHLANDS SCOTLAND – CHURCH OF SCOTLAND – Royal Courts of Justice Most Famous Identity Case in the World
HRH Princess Alexandra The Honourable Lady Ogilvy – “The Royal Family Identity Theft Story” – THE QUEEN’S SOLICITORS IN SCOTLAND MORTON FRASER – THE CLAN SUTHERLAND – “THE ROYAL WARRANT IDENTITY STORY” – THE MASTER OF SUTHERLAND – THE EARL OF SUTHERLAND – THE DUKE OF SUTHERLAND – THE ROYAL REGIMENT OF SCOTLAND – THE ARGYLL AND SUTHERLAND HIGHLANDERS MUSEUM – HM Queen Elizabeth II Head of State “Sovereign Powers” Gerald 6th Duke of Sutherland Marquess of Stafford Earl Gower – Gerald J. H. Carroll Forged Birth Certificate “Sealed Records” – THE COURT OF THE LORD LYON EDINBURGH SCOTLAND – LORD LYON KING OF ARMS DR JOSEPH MORROW QC – ALEXANDER DOUGLAS HAMILTON 16TH DUKE OF HAMILTON AND 13TH DUKE OF BRANDON – “THE KEEPER OF THE PALACE OF HOLYROODHOUSE IDENTITY STORY” – LORD HIGH CONSTABLE OF SCOTLAND MERLIN HAY 24TH EARL OF ERROLL – HRH THE PRINCE EDWARD DUKE OF KENT – HRH THE PRINCE MICHAEL OF KENT – HRH THE PRINCESS MARINA DUCHESS OF KENT AND GEORGE 5TH DUKE OF SUTHERLAND – GERALD 6TH DUKE OF SUTHERLAND TRUST = NAME-SWITCH = CARROLL FOUNDATION TRUST – HM KING EDWARD VIII – HRH THE PRINCE EDWARD DUKE OF WINDSOR “THE GODFATHER” – SIR WINSTON S. CHURCHILL “THE GODFATHER” – HRH THE PRINCE OF WALES DUKE OF ROTHESAY – THE LORD HIGH COMMISSIONER TO THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF THE CHURCH OF SCOTLAND HRH PRINCE WILLIAM EARL OF STRATHEARN – DORNOCH CATHEDRAL DORNOCH HIGHLANDS SCOTLAND – HOUSE OF TONGUE HIGHLANDS SCOTLAND – DUNROBIN CASTLE GOLSPIE HIGHLANDS SCOTLAND – HM LORD LIEUTENANT OF SUTHERLAND DR MONICA MAIN – Royal Courts of Justice Most Famous Identity Theft Liquidation Bank Fraud Bribery Case in the World
HRH Prince Edward Earl of Wessex -“The Nancy Hurrell Harp Concert Identity Theft Story” – SCOTLAND FIRST MINISTER NICOLA STURGEON – AXIS – CABINET SECRETARY FOR JUSTICE OF SCOTLAND KEITH BROWN – AXIS – AMPERSAND ADVOCATES EDINBURGH SCOTLAND – “THE SUPREME COURTS OF SCOTLAND IDENTITY THEFT CASE STORY” – THE PALACE OF HOLYROODHOUSE KEEPER ALEXANDER 16TH DUKE OF HAMILTON – AXIS – LORD HIGH CONSTABLE OF SCOTLAND MERLIN HAY 24TH EARL OF ERROLL – AXIS – THE COURT OF THE LORD LYON EDINBURGH SCOTLAND – HM Queen Elizabeth II Head of State Gerald 6th Duke of Sutherland “Sealed Records” – CHURCH OF ENGLAND – HRH THE PRINCE WILLIAM DUKE OF CAMBRIDGE – HRH THE PRINCE OF WALES DUKE OF ROTHESAY – HRH THE PRINCESS MARINA DUCHESS OF KENT AND GEORGE 5TH DUKE OF SUTHERLAND – GERALD 6TH DUKE OF SUTHERLAND TRUST = NAME-SWITCH = CARROLL FOUNDATION TRUST – HM KING EDWARD VIII – HRH THE PRINCE EDWARD DUKE OF WINDSOR “THE GODFATHER” – SIR WINSTON S. CHURCHILL “THE GODFATHER” – THE QUEEN’S CHAPEL OF THE SAVOY STRAND LONDON – DORNOCH CATHEDRAL HIGHLANDS SCOTLAND – ROYAL ARCHIVES WINDSOR CASTLE – DUNROBIN CASTLE GOLSPIE HIGHLANDS SCOTLAND – CHURCH OF SCOTLAND – Royal Courts of Justice Most Famous Identity Case in the World